Moment 1 · Make the call · Q4 0:15 · PIT 24–24 CLE
With 0:15 left and the score tied, what should CLE do?
4th & 8 at the PIT 38: go for it, kick or punt?
CLEPIT goal
What should CLE do?
ShouldaSports · NFL · Thursday, October 1, 2026 · Week 4
PIT at CLE
Moment 1 · Make the call · Q4 0:15 · PIT 24–24 CLE
4th & 8 at the PIT 38: go for it, kick or punt?
What should CLE do?
Moment 2 · The flag · Q4 1:51 · PIT 16–24 CLE
What if the flag hadn't been thrown?
What happened: No play. Penalty: defensive pass interference (CLE), 8 yards.
Moment 3 · Make the call · Q4 5:40 · PIT 16–24 CLE
4th & 5 at the PIT 37: go for it or punt?
What should PIT do?
Moment 4 · Pick the turning point · Q1 5:49 · PIT 0–0 CLE
Four plays. Which one decided it?
Any play with a clear alternative has a Shoulda? button: see the swing and play the rest out.